Backward Glance: Former Chicago Synagogues

One day years ago, as I rode my bike through the old Chicago neighborhood known as Wicker Park, I glimpsed at what looked like Hebrew lettering on a brick building with a blue cross. I stopped to investigate and discovered the building formerly housed Temple Beth-El. I was stunned, because that was the name of the temple I attended from age five to 18 — except it was located in West Rogers Park.

beth_el

The former Temple Beth-El, 2126 W. Crystal St, was at this location until 1925.

I looked up the website for Temple Beth-El — it’s now in Northbrook — and learned that it was on Crystal Street from 1902 until 1925, when it moved to Logan Square. The congregation moved again, in 1956, to the Touhy Avenue building where I spent a good part of my childhood.  Intrigued, I then delved into the history of Chicago’s Jewish neighborhoods and found that every generation of Jews has migrated from one part of the city to another. In the 1960s, as I was growing up in a predominantly Jewish neighborhood on the North Side, the Jews were on the move again, this time to the suburbs.

bnai_israel

The former Congregation B’nai Israel was located at 5453 W. Jackson Blvd.

People leave, the buildings stay behind Frederick J. Nachman has posted his collection of 282 photographs of former Chicago synagogues on Flickr, and I’ve copied several to my blog today. Nothing has given me a feel for what was left behind the way these remarkable photographs do. I’m surprised there are so many former synagogues, surprised there are so many grand and imposing buildings. I interviewed the photographer (FJN) by email to learn more about how he went about finding these buildings.

Frances: How many former Chicago synagogues have you photographed?

FJN: About 90.

Frances: How long have you been photographing Chicago’s synagogues?

FJN: I started 15 months ago.  The first was the former KAM on 33rd and Indiana, which sadly was almost destroyed by fire.  The inspiration came from Chicago’s Forgotten Synagogues by Robb Packer.

Frances: Do you always go inside the buildings if they are open to the public?

FJN: Almost never because of time constraints.  I photographed the interior of the former Anshe Sholom in Lawndale because the caretaker told me about the original stained-glass windows.

beth_jacob_anshe_kroz

The former Beth Jacob Anshe Kroz was located at South Drake St and W. 15th St.

Frances: Many old synagogues on the South and West Sides were larger and more ornate than the ones built in later years on the North Side. Do you know why?

 

FJN: I believe it’s a combination of the North Side synagogues being built after the era of ornate architectural styles and the relative wealth of each congregation.

Frances: I noticed on Flickr you’ve tagged these photos to various groups. Have you found other photographers who share your interest in former Chicago synagogues? What do you like about being able to share on Flickr?

FJN: One in particular, Elizar Appleton, has been very helpful.  Not only has he pointed out a few I missed, he’s also translated Hebrew inscriptions.  Flickr has brought insights from people outside Chicago and the U.S., including a woman from New York who belonged to the same congregation in Brooklyn as my wife and has published a book on lost New York synagogues.

Kehilath_jacob

The former Kehilath Jacob was located at 3757 W. Douglas Blvd.

Frances: Do you have a favorite?

FJN: One congregation, two synagogues: The First Roumanian Congregation.  The Douglas Boulevard temple is simply beautiful and features cornerstones for both the synagogue and the present church.  The previous one is the last remaining former synagogue in the Maxwell Street area, and my grandparents worshipped there after coming to the U.S. in 1900.

First_Roumanian_Congregation

The former First Roumanian Congregation at 3622 W. Douglas Blvd.

Frances: Do you have an emotional response when you see these buildings, and has that evolved over the duration of your project?

FJN: Each building is unique and evokes an emotional response.  It might be that family members worshipped there, a distinctive architectural feature, the size (large and small) or the setting within the neighborhood.  Even as I reached my 90th structure, I still felt the excitement of actually seeing the former synagogue before me, rather than on a photo on the Internet, and imagining the time Jews worshipped there.

south_side_congregation

The former South Side Hebrew Congregation at 7357 S. Chappel.

Frances: On Flickr you commented that you use the Chicago Ancestors Collection at the Newberry Library and Google Maps street views for this project. How exactly do you go about finding former synagogues?

FJN: The Chicago Ancestors Collection has the most extensive list of former synagogues.  Entries vary from having almost no information to data on construction dates, movements and the like.  The American Jewish Yearbook from 1919-1920 also includes a list of Chicago congregations.  I entered each address on Google Maps and found one of the following in the Street View: an empty lot, a building that definitely was not a former synagogue or one that most likely housed a temple.  Once I arrived at a site in West Rogers Park and found the building had recently been torn down.

All photographs courtesy of Frederick J. Nachman and found on Flickr.

, , , ,

8 Responses to Backward Glance: Former Chicago Synagogues

  1. Marshall Rosenthal December 17, 2009 at 2:56 pm #

    Thanks for an informative entry!

  2. Danny December 17, 2009 at 4:07 pm #

    Absolutely fascinating. I can’t wait to go look at the rest. There’s a small former synagogue right near Von Steuben that last I saw was a Korean church. The metal railings were a pattern of Jewish stars and when the church moved in they just sawed off the top and bottom of the stars.

  3. Rabbi Paul F. Cohen December 18, 2009 at 10:18 am #

    Love the photos. What a great piece you put together. Thank you for doing this, Frances. Shabbat Shalom and Happy Hanukkah.

  4. Jerry December 21, 2009 at 9:41 am #

    Terrific. Who knew what you were doing on Tuesdays, Thursdays, and Sundays…

  5. Brule Laker December 21, 2009 at 8:45 pm #

    Thanks Jerry. Never on Sunday; I need a day of rest.

  6. Jim December 22, 2009 at 6:52 am #

    Great interview!

  7. Carey Wintergreen March 14, 2013 at 10:17 am #

    The former South Side Hebrew Congregation pictured above is located at 7355 S. Chappel Avenue (1927), Morris L. Komar, Architect. An earlier South Side Hebrew Congregation Kehilath Anshe Dorum (c. 1880) is located at 3435 S. Indiana Avenue.

  8. Frances Archer March 17, 2013 at 4:13 pm #

    Carey, the author of the book, Fred Nachman, discuss his family’s connections to South Side Hebrew Congregation in the book. His grandfather worshipped at the Chappel Avenue location, and his uncle, who turned 101 this year, attended Hebrew School at the 59th Street location. Update: the book I’m referring to is not mentioned on this post but on a later post. Nachman published his photographs of former synagogues in the book, There Used to Be A Synagogue Here, in 2013. I reviewed the book in this post: . Sorry for sounding confused, and thanks for stopping by.

Powered by WordPress. Designed by WooThemes